ECONOMIC AND LEGAL ASPECTS OF IMPLEMENTING THE PRACTICE OF THE ECHR IN THE NATIONAL JUDICIAL SYSTEM OF UKRAINE (CRIMINAL AND CIVIL CASES)
##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.main##
##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.sidebar##
Abstract
Implementing the decisions of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) within Ukraine’s national judicial system, particularly in criminal and civil proceedings, is a pressing issue in the context of the country’s European integration and ongoing legal reforms. Despite Ukraine's formal commitments under the European Convention on Human Rights, systemic deficiencies, including chronic underfunding of enforcement institutions, continue to undermine compliance. This has resulted in mounting financial liabilities, encompassing compensation payments and reputational costs, thereby imposing a substantial strain on the state budget. The relevance of the study lies in the growing economic consequences of Ukraine's non-compliance with ECHR decisions, especially in cases of systemic violations such as Burmich and Others v. Ukraine, which exposed institutional failures in executing domestic judgments. The objective of this research is to conduct a comprehensive economic and legal analysis of the implementation of ECHR decisions in Ukraine, with a focus on criminal and civil justice. The objective of the present study is twofold: firstly, to identify the key economic risks and institutional shortcomings affecting compliance, and secondly, to propose reforms to mitigate these risks and shortcomings. The methodology employed is founded upon the principles of the comparative legal method, formal logical analysis, and systemic-structural approach. The examination encompasses national legislation, case law, and international best practices. The results of the study demonstrate that the primary barrier to effective implementation is the lack of dedicated budgetary funding, despite recent efforts by the Ministry of Justice to improve enforcement. The article concludes that it is essential for sustainable reform that legal obligations are aligned with financial planning.
How to Cite
##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.details##
criminal proceedings, civil proceedings, budgetary impact, financial liability
Council of Europe (2023). Implementation of ECtHR Judgments – Ukraine. Available at: https://www.coe.int/en/web/execution/ukraine
European Court of Human Rights (2017, October 12). Burmich and Others v. Ukraine, Apps. Nos. 46852/13, 47786/13, 54125/13, 56605/13, and 3653/14. HUDOC. Available at: https://hudoc.exec.coe.int/eng?i=004-47973
Department for the Execution of Judgments of the ECHR (2024). Country Profile – Ukraine. Available at: https://www.coe.int/en/web/execution/ukraine-country-profile
Ministry of Justice of Ukraine (2024). Annual Report on the Execution of ECtHR Judgments. Available at: https://minjust.gov.ua
Council of Europe (2023b). Supervision of the execution of judgments and decisions of the European Court of Human Rights. Available at: https://www.coe.int/en/web/cm/execution-judgments
HUDOC (2024). 1501st meeting (June 2024) (DH) – Action Plan (21/05/2024) – Communication from Ukraine concerning the cases of Zavaliy and others v. Ukraine (Application No. 23342/14), Tryapyshko v. Ukraine (Application No. 59577/12), USTIMENKO v. Ukraine (Application No. 32053/13), Generalnyy Budivelnyy Menedzhment v. Ukraine (Application No. 11925/09) and Skvyrasilrybgosp, VAT v. Ukraine (Application No. 27128/11) [PONOMARYOV v. Ukraine] (anglais uniquement). Available at: https://hudoc.exec.coe.int/ENG#{%22execidentifier%22:[%22DH-DD(2024)586E%22]}
PRAVO.UA. (2021). Burmich and Others v. Ukraine: What are the consequences for the state and the applicants? Available at: https://www.coe.int/en/web/execution/-/burmych-and-others-v-ukraine
Ukrainian Helsinki Human Rights Union. (2023). Assessment of Ukraine’s compliance with ECtHR Available at: judgments.https://ccl.org.ua/en/positions/for-what-ukrainians-often-judged-with-ukraine-in-the-echr/
Venice Commission. (2021). Opinion on the implementation of ECtHR judgments in Ukraine. Available at: https://www.venice.coe.int/webforms/documents/?opinion=1024&year=all
Izarova, I., Uhrynovska, O., & Hartman, Y. (2024). Procedural issues in compensation cases: Insights from court practice in Ukraine. In S. Nate (Ed.), Ukraine’s journey to recovery, reform and post‑war reconstruction (pp. 119–142). Springer. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-66434-2_9
Nate, S. (Ed.) (2024). Implementation of the European Court of Human Rights judgements as an instrument for recovery of Ukraine and its accession to the European Union. In Ukraine’s journey to recovery, reform and post‑war reconstruction (pp. 143–156). Springer. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-66434-2_10
Audretsch, D., Momtaz, P. P., Motuzenko, H., & Vismara, S. (2023). The economic costs of the Russia–Ukraine war: A synthetic control study of (lost) entrepreneurship. arXiv. Available at: https://arxiv.org/abs/2303.02773
Liadze, I., Macchiarelli, C., Mortimer‑Lee, P., & Sánchez Juanino, P. (2023). Economic costs of the Russia–Ukraine war. The World Economy, 46(4), 874–886. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/twec.13336
Askari, H., & Mirakhor, A. (2020). Utilizing the European Convention on Human Rights to transfer frozen Russian assets to Ukraine. SAIS Review of International Affairs. Available at: https://saisreview.sais.jhu.edu/utilizing-the-european-convention-on-human-rights-to-transfer-frozen-russian-assets-to-ukraine/
Kononenko, R. (2015). IMF lending and economic growth: An empirical analysis of Ukraine. arXiv. Available at: https://arxiv.org/abs/1509.01741
Korovkin, D., & Makarin, A. (2020). Production networks and war. arXiv. Available at: https://arxiv.org/abs/2011.14756
Obrizan, M. (2022). Poverty, unemployment and displacement in Ukraine: Three months into the war. arXiv. Available at: https://arxiv.org/abs/2211.05628
Pilkov, K. (2022). Reopening cases following judgments of the European Court of Human Rights: Room for a European consensus? Access to Justice in Eastern Europe. SSRN. Available at: https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=4224716
Council of Europe, Committee of Ministers (2023). Supervision of the execution of judgments of the European Court of Human Rights: 17th annual report of the Committee of Ministers [PDF]. Council of Europe. Available at: https://edoc.coe.int/en/european-convention-on-human-rights/11835-supervision-of-the-execution-of-judgments-of-the-european-court-of-human-rights-2023-17th-annual-report-of-the-committee-of-ministers.html
Ministry of Justice of Ukraine (2014). Order on improving the practice of implementing ECHR decisions [Unpublished internal document]. Available at: https://share.google/cNbZXIMTV8XLGffkH
Focacci, C. N., Kovac, M., & Spruk, R. (2022, June 10). The perils of Kremlin’s influence: Evidence from Ukraine [Preprint]. arXiv. DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2206.04950
Izarova, I., Hartman, Y., & Nate, S. (2023). War damages compensation: A case study on Ukraine. F1000Research, 12, 1250. DOI: https://doi.org/10.12688/f1000research.136162.1
Komarov, V., & Tsuvina, T. (2021). The impact of the ECHR and the case law of the ECtHR on civil procedure in Ukraine. Access to Justice in Eastern Europe, 1(9), 79–101. DOI: https://doi.org/10.33327/AJEE-18-4.1-a000047
Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine (2022, October 18). Law No. 2689‑IX and Law No. 2690‑IX: Amendments regarding execution of European Court of Human Rights judgments. Official Parliamentary Bulletin. Available at: https://www.rada.gov.ua/news/razom/229308.html
Council of Europe, Committee of Ministers (2018, December 6). Execution of ECtHR judgments – Zhovner group v. Ukraine; Ivanov v. Ukraine. 1331st meeting, agenda item H46-34. Strasbourg. Available at: https://rm.coe.int/09000016808f00a7
Council of Europe, Committee of Ministers (2019, September 25). Execution of ECtHR judgments – Zhovner group; Ivanov v. Ukraine. 1355th meeting, agenda item H46-28. Strasbourg. Available at: https://rm.coe.int/0900001680972f0b
European Court of Human Rights (2005, April 5). Afanasyev v. Ukraine, Application No. 38722/02, Judgment of 5 April 2005. HUDOC. Available at: https://justice.pappers.fr/decision/a699d18e4c2aaf1119d4168063f61dd8c80c30f7
European Court of Human Rights (2012, May 15). Kaverzin v. Ukraine, Application No. 23893/03, Judgment of 15 May 2012. HUDOC. Available at: https://rm.coe.int/0900001680972f08
International Monetary Fund (2021, April 23). Assessing the Macroeconomic Impact of Structural Reforms in Ukraine (Working Paper No. 2021/100). IMF. Available at: https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/WP/Issues/2021/04/23/Assessing-the-Macroeconomic-Impact-of-Structural-Reforms-in-Ukraine-50345
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.