Published: Jun 7, 2018

  Olesia Vashchuk


The article is devoted to the research of issues of the formation of the modern system of evaluation of effectiveness and motivation of managers and workers of an enterprise in the context of European integration processes in Ukraine. The object is theoretical and practical foundations of creating an efficient motivational profile of an organization with the help of formation of the modern system of employee efficiency analysis and formation of an individual system of employee motivation at the enterprise based on research of incentive systems of developed countries and EU countries. The main research objectives are established: determination of key priorities for the formation of the system of valuation and motivation; formation of an algorithm and economic and mathematical model of the system of evaluation and motivation of personnel efficiency, zoning of boundary priorities and formation of a matrix of opportunities, formation of an effective system for improving the system of personnel motivation and evaluation, and a model of the system of improvement of personnel motivation means. Methodology. The conducted comparative analysis of various motivation systems existing in the EU countries and the most developed countries allowed developing a hypothesis about the necessity to form a more effective system of personnel evaluation and motivation that would correspond to general European values and criteria. A model of motivation is proposed that is developed on the basis of the Management Functional Assessment Model (MFAM), which is elaborated by researchers of Sheffield Hallam University (Great Britain) and the company “IVA Consulting Group”. MFAM is based on six main management functions: Forecasting/Planning, Organization, Motivation, Control, Coordination, and Communication. Its main advantages are the evaluation by three parameters: personnel loyalty; personnel performance; company’s attractiveness in the labour market, information about which is available in free and convenient access. Evaluation of the enterprise management system based on the functional model (MFAM) is carried out by questionnaire method. Questions of the express evaluation questionnaire are divided into five groups according to model criteria. By an obtained mathematical model, analytical indicators, and grading scale, we define zones of effectiveness where enterprise management is taking place and build a matrix of opportunities for development of enterprise efficiency. Result. The research conducted confirms the methodology’s efficiency, its uniqueness, and instrumental suitability. Based on experimental calculations, the algorithm of formation of performance evaluation system is determined, gradients and limits of the enterprise development are identified, the matrix of opportunities is formed, directions to improve the system of personnel motivation and evaluation are formed, and the model of the system for improving personnel motivation means is developed. Results of the enterprise personnel performance evaluation according to the developed system of indicators gave a possibility for managers of the company: to make a separate generalized profile of the appropriate group of the most successful co-workers; to form profiles of ideal co-workers, which are built given the idea of the leadership about the optimal combination of motivating factors, and to form effective directions for improving the motivation system.

How to Cite

Article views: 420 | PDF Downloads: 237



European integration motivation criteria, motivation system, MFAM, performance evaluation, matrix of opportunities, motivation system improvement, motivation model


Day G.S., Wensley R. (1988). Assessing advantage: a framework for diagnosing a competitive superiority, Marketing Strategy, p. 127-158.

Dykan N. V. (2008). Menedzhment: navch. posibnyk [Fundamentals of management: the Navy messenger]. Kyiv: Znannya.

Hutorova O. O. (2009). Osnovy menedzhmentu: navch. Posibnyk [Fundamentals of management: the Navy messenger]. Kharkiv: KhNAU (in Ukraine).

Verkhohlyadova N. I., Yadranskyy D. M., Ivannikova N. A. (2008). Ekonomika pidpryyemstva [Economy of enterprises]. Kyiv: «Vydavnychyy dim «Profesional».

Korytko S. (2012). Formuvannya systemy motyvatsiyi pratsi na pidpryyemstvi [Formation of the system of motivation of labor at the enterprise]. Retrieved from:

Iziumtseva N.V., Myronchuk H.V. (2012). Orhanizatsiia systemy motyvatsii bankivskoho personalu v umovakh postkryzovoho rozvytku ekonomiky [Organization of the system of motivation of banking personnel in the conditions of post-crisis economic development]. Menedzhment personalu: Visnyk Universytetu bankivskoi spravy Natsionalnoho banku Ukrainy. Management of personnel: Herald of the University of Banking of the National Bank of Ukraine, №1, pp. 279-283.

Iliash O.I., Kaperyz M.V. (2011). Posylennia motyvatsii pratsi v systemi upravlinnia trudovym potentsialom pidpryiemstva [Strengthening the motivation of labor in the system of management of the labor potential of the enterprise]. Economy, planning and management of the branch: Scientific Bulletin of the NLTI of Ukraine, Vol. 21.2, pp. 167-171.

Kindermann H. (2002). Formuvannia mekhanizmu motyvatsii pratsivnykiv aparatu upravlinnia pidpryiemstva [Formation of the mechanism of motivation of employees of the enterprise management machinery]. Management and entrepreneurship in Ukraine: stages of formation and development problems: Bulletin of the National University "Lviv Polytechnic". Lviv. Vol. 457, pp. 122-128.

Kozak K.B. (2011). Vplyv motyvatsii na efektyvnist vykorystannia ta rozvytku trudovoho potentsialu personalu [Influence of motivation on efficiency of use and development of labor potential of personnel]. Economy of food industry, No. 1, pp. 69-74.

Kushneryk O.V. (2012), Zarubizhni modeli motyvatsii pratsi personalu na pidpryiemstvi [Foreign models of personnel motivation at the enterprise]. Bulletin of the University of Ukraine, No. 15, pp. 98-103.

Larka MI, Zorina M.O. (2016). Suchasna model systemy stymuliuvannia najmanoho personalu na vyrobnychomu pidpryiemstvi [Modern model of the system of incentives for hired personnel at a production enterprise]. Technical progress and production efficiency. No 14/7. Retrieved from: //

Muzychenko-Kozlovskyj A.V., Kolodijchuk A.V. (2011) Osnovni elementy mekhanizmu motyvuvannia pratsivnykiv [The main elements of the mechanism of motivation of workers]. Scientific Bulletin of NLTU of Ukraine. Vol. 21.6, pp. 361-367.

Nikitin Y.O., Rukas-Pasichnyuk V.G .(2016). Suchasni modeli ta mekhanizmy motyvatsii personalu ukrainskykh pidpryiemstv [Modern models and mechanisms of motivation of personnel of Ukrainian enterprises]. Topical problems of the economy. Vol. 4 (154), pp. 238-353.

Potemkin O.V. (2011). Systemnyj pidkhid u motyvatsii pratsivnykiv bankivskoi sfery [Systemic approach to the motivation of banking industry workers]. Economic forum. No. 1. Retrieved from:

Semenov AG, Sharko A.I. (2009). Aktualizatsiia teorij motyvatsii ta stymuliuvannia pratsi personalu na promyslovykh pidpryiemstvakh [Actualization of theories of motivation and stimulation of labor at the industrial enterprises]. State and regions. No.7, pp. 179-185.

Semikina M.V. (2011). Nova paradyhma motyvatsii pratsi v systemi rozvytku sotsialno-trudovykh vidnosyn [New paradigm of labor motivation in the system of development of social-labor relations]. Economy and management. No. 3, pp. 11-117.

Temchenko O., Lisnichenko O. (2010). Vrakhuvannia motyvatsijnoi skladovoi pry rozrobtsi mekhanizmu materialnoho stymuliuvannia robitnykiv na promyslovykh pidpryiemstvakh [Taking into account the motivational component when developing the mechanism of material stimulation of workers at industrial enterprises]. Economic analysis. Vol. 7, pp. 350-353.

Watson P., Maslow D., Chileshe N. Deploying Total Quality Management in Russia (2004) European Quality Vol. 11, No. 2, pp. 58-71.

Watson P., Chileshe N., Maslow D. A (2004). New Model For Obtaining Sustainable Competitive Advantage. Construction Industry Development 2nd Postgraduate Conference – Cape Town, South Africa, 10-12 October, pp. 129-141.

Zhyvko Z.B. (2010). Mekhanizm motyvuvannia ta modeli motyvatsii personalu na vuhledobuvnykh pidpryiemstvakh [Mechanism of motivation and models of personnel motivation at coal-mining enterprises]. Management and marketing. Science and Economics, no. 1, pp. 86–91.